If you’re like most insurance agencies, you’re swimming in numbers—sales figures, retention rates, revenue growth, you name it. But what do those numbers really mean? And how do you know if you’re doing okay or falling behind?
That’s where insurance agency performance metrics come in. Tracking these metrics isn’t just a good idea—it’s essential for running a successful agency. But here’s the kicker: you also need to understand what’s “normal” in the industry (so you’re not comparing yourself to unrealistic standards) and what’s “natural” (because growth doesn’t happen in a straight line).
Let’s break it down into actionable insights you can use to keep your agency on track.
Key Metrics and Industry Benchmarks
Metrics are like the report card for your agency—they reveal what’s working, what needs fine-tuning, and where you can excel. Here are the key metrics to track, along with industry benchmarks to help you measure success:
- Sales Metrics:
- New Premium Sales: A producer focused solely on new business should aim for $45,000 in new personal lines premium monthly, or $60,000 in new commercial lines premium monthly. This doesn’t happen by accident—it requires consistent effort and clear goals. We share more about this specific topic in our blog: How To Set Insurance Producer Sales Goals
- Retention Rates:
Retention is the backbone of your agency’s success, and it comes in three flavors:- Premium Retention: A strong agency retains 90–95% of its total written premium year over year.
- Client Retention: Keeping 88–92% of your clients is a healthy range; dipping below 85% means it’s time to address service or communication issues.
- Policy Retention: Aim to retain 85–90% of individual policies. Lower rates may signal missed cross-sell opportunities or competitive pressures.
- Revenue Growth:
Agencies should target 5–10% annual growth in written premium. Surpassing this benchmark is great, but make sure it doesn’t come at the expense of service quality or team burnout. - Claims Ratio:
This measures claims paid out compared to premiums collected. A low claims ratio is essential for profitability and maintaining carrier relationships. If it’s creeping up, dig into the reasons behind the trend. - Productivity Metrics:
Track response times, client follow-ups, and policies managed per producer. If these numbers feel off, it’s a sign your team might be stretched too thin or processes need optimization. Review more productivity tips here!
What Is Natural and Why Does It Matters?
Metrics don’t exist in a vacuum. Fluctuations are part of the game, even for the highest-performing agencies. The trick is understanding what’s “natural” for your agency so you can set realistic goals without unnecessary stress:
- Seasonal Variations:
Some months are naturally slower (hello, January), while others buzz with activity (looking at you, June). These rhythms are predictable and can guide your planning. - Client Behavior Trends:
Clients procrastinate, shop around, and often renew at the last minute. It’s not a reflection of your service—it’s just human nature.
Recognizing these patterns allows you to focus on long-term trends and adjust your strategies accordingly. This is why we strongly recommend investing in Strategic Business Planning to help identify and adapt to these natural fluctuations with clarity and confidence.
Using Metrics to Set and Adjust Goals
Metrics aren’t just about looking back—they’re tools to guide future growth. Here’s how to use them effectively:
- Set Achievable Targets:
If your client retention rate is at 85%, aim for 87% next quarter—not 95%. Incremental progress keeps goals realistic and team morale high. - Adjust Goals Over Time:
As your agency grows and markets shift, revisit your targets to ensure they align with your current reality. - Compare Normal vs. Natural:
Use industry benchmarks (normal) alongside your agency’s unique rhythms (natural) to stay balanced and avoid overreactions.
Tools & Tips for Tracking Insurance Agency Performance Metrics
Tracking doesn’t have to be a headache. With the right tools and systems, you can keep your finger on the pulse of your agency:
- Invest in the Right Tools:
Use your agency management system effectively, along with analytics dashboards. These are lifesavers for tracking performance with minimal effort. - Establish a Consistent Process:
Create a standardized workflow for collecting and analyzing data. Consistency ensures you’re comparing apples to apples. - Set Up Regular Reviews:
Monthly check-ins provide a clear picture of progress and flag areas that need attention before they escalate. - Train Your Team:
Everyone should understand the metrics that matter and how their roles impact the bigger picture. This fosters accountability and teamwork.
Conclusion
Understanding insurance agency performance metrics isn’t just about crunching numbers—it’s about building a roadmap for sustainable growth. By knowing what’s “normal” in the industry and embracing the “natural” ebbs and flows of business, you can set realistic, informed goals that drive success without unnecessary stress.
Metrics aren’t scary—they’re your agency’s secret weapon. So, start tracking, adjust as needed, and remember: progress, not perfection, is the ultimate goal.
Looking for more ways to empower your agency? Consider leveraging the Agency Performance Partners Assessment Program to gain a comprehensive understanding of your agency’s current performance. This program dives into key metrics, compares them against industry benchmarks, and identifies opportunities for growth. Whether it’s streamlining workflows, boosting retention, or achieving operational excellence, the assessment provides actionable insights tailored to your unique needs.
Ready to take the guesswork out of performance improvement? Check out our resources and let’s make sustainable success happen—one step at a time!
🔥 Dive into our latest blog and unlock the secrets of How To Run An Insurance Agency: Evaluating Insurance Agency Performance
🎉 Get our FREE State of Culture of Independent Insurance Agencies
🚀 Ready to elevate your style? 🕶️ Explore our Ridiculously Amazing Insurance Agent Swag Store!
📈 Book a meeting with our Agency Performance Partners and unlock tailored strategies for unparalleled success. Elevate your agency’s game – schedule your consultation now!
🤝 We’re Agency Performance Partners; APP is your insurance agency’s best friend when it comes to training, strategies, brutal truth & tough love that’ll grow your agency with hugs & high fives along the way….just like a BFF. LEARN MORE!
